Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Database\Driver\mysql\Connection::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Logger\LogMessageParser::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\dblog\Logger\DbLog::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\ultimate_cron\Logger\WatchdogLogger::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Logger\LoggerChannelFactory::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Session\AccountProxy::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Site\Settings::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Cache\CacheFactory::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Cache\ChainedFastBackendFactory::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Cache\DatabaseCacheTagsChecksum::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Cache\DatabaseBackendFactory::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Cache\DatabaseBackend::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Config\CachedStorage::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Config\ExtensionInstallStorage::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Cache\DatabaseBackend::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Cache\DatabaseBackend::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Extension\ModuleHandler::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\DependencyInjection\ClassResolver::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property ArrayObject::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Validation\ConstraintManager::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Config\TypedConfigManager::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Drupal\Core\Config\ConfigFactory::$_serviceId is deprecated in /home/raynords/tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/core/lib/Drupal/Component/DependencyInjection/Container.php on line 288 Warner, Harry Jr.
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/
enAmon Lhaw: [Excerpts from letter sent to Shaw, discusses Tolkien and music, including Bruce Pelz's Tolkien compositions, with introduction and commentary from Greg Shaw]
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/3021
<span>Amon Lhaw: [Excerpts from letter sent to Shaw, discusses Tolkien and music, including Bruce Pelz's Tolkien compositions, with introduction and commentary from Greg Shaw]</span>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Fri, 03/29/2019 - 19:47</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Zine Title</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/595" hreflang="und">Entmoot</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/508" hreflang="und">Shaw, Greg</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Item Type</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/368" hreflang="und">Letter</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Year</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/596" hreflang="und">1965</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Issue Info</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/568" hreflang="und">#1 / June</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="field field--name-field-pages field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Pages</div>
<div class="field-item">3-4</div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-image-link field--type-link field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Image Link</div>
<div class="field-item"><a href="http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/85">http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/85</a></div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-body field--type-text-with-summary field--label-hidden field-item"><p>[page 3] AMON LHAW Amon Lhaw was the anceint @ancient@ "Hill of Hearing" at Tol Brandir; I have dubbed this column of comments from the readers that on the spur of the moment - a superior title is desired, and any suggestions welcomed. First, here are two comments from HARRY WARNER JR., 423 Summit Avenue, Hagerstown, Maryland: "Bruce Pelz has published several musical settings of Tolkien poems. They consist of the vocal line and indication of the chords that should accompany the sing @song@, not a fully-written out accompaniment. It would be interesting to discover how many different notions exist on what kind of music the Ring poems should get. I imagine that most Tolkien fans would expect something simple, folksongish in character. But I don't remember much referance to musical instruments in the Tolkien novels, certainly the situations under which most songs were sung pre- vented accompaniment, and does this mean the songs should be set as unaccompanied meter, or should they have irregularities like most old folk songs? Should the settings sound in general like folk music of some part of the British Isles to go with the English allusions in the literary side of the Tolkien books? Should they be sung by men at all, since such tiny creatures as hobbits undoubtably had high-pitched voices from short vocal chords?" Well, now I don't really know, Harry ... you raised some interesting points there. Nothing in the Tolkien books suggests that the hobbits had unnaturally hich-pitched voices ... the suggestion that they might is there, but I can't think of any singular reference. Perhaps it is the same sort of thing as old ERB, who apparently never got used to the idea of green men being fifteen feet tall.. he used to speak of John Carter and Tars Tarkas fighting "shoulder to shoulder", which would of course be impossible unless Carter was standing on a hill, or Tars Tarkas was lying on his back. The question of music is also a moot point. I think that folksong, that is, modern folksong, type would sound well with the hobbits -- but what of the elves? What kind of music do you suggest forr @for@ the elven songs? Comments, anyone? Here's Harry again, on another subject: "There is ... evidence that some highly personal matters are interwoven into the novels. Notice the importance of the name Tuck and its similarity to the start of his own name. Someone else, Gina Clarke I believe, pointed out that so many names in the books of characters are simply two or three letters of the alphabet spelled out phonetically. This could mean that friends or relatives are symbolized by those characters. Unfortunately, I doubt that a century from now, learned men will spend years tracing down the origins of the Ring novels and hobbits as they do today for Lewis Carroll's Alice books. My opinion of Tolkien as a story-teller and as a writer is on the lukewarmish side." Even ignoring that last sentence, I'm fairly sure my co-editor will have a few comments on that, but in the meantime, I'll put in my two bits worth. First of all, I was unaware that learned men were scouring Carroll's books for references to real characters. If they were, a lot of the time they are just [page 4] wasting time, for some of his poems just spell out the persons @person's@ name reading down the first line. As for the names in Tolkien, I don't really know about the hobbits. Judging from his patronizing attitude towards them (he never had the heart to kill off Bilbo), I find it altogether possible that they could be named for friends -- but I don't know. I'm sure someone out there must be better informed than I. As for the names of non-hobbits, I'm inclined to doubt that theory. Their origins can probably be traced to his interest in linguistics and other sources. For instance, many of the dwarves can be traced directly back to the old Norse lays -- Thorin Oakenshield, from _the Hobbit_ @_The Hobbit_@, for one.. Gandalf himself was originally a dwarf in the Eddas. Other names that can be thusly traced: Dwalin (Dvalin), Dain Bifur, Bofur, Bombur, Nori, Thror, Dori, Ori, Fili, Kili. I'm not sure which of those were actually names of the dwarves in either the Ring trilogy or Thorin's crew in _The Hobbit_, but I think it does indicate that any dwarves not actually there were derived from the same root.</p>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-hidden field-item">IL-00090</div>
Fri, 29 Mar 2019 19:47:25 +0000Anonymous3021 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cmsTIW: [Letter discussing music in Tolkien in response to topic in Entmoot #2 , as well as Tolkien script and meaning of Middle Earth with in-line commentary by Greg Shaw]
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/3061
<span>TIW: [Letter discussing music in Tolkien in response to topic in Entmoot #2 , as well as Tolkien script and meaning of Middle Earth with in-line commentary by Greg Shaw]</span>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Fri, 03/29/2019 - 19:47</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Zine Title</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/595" hreflang="und">Entmoot</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Item Type</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/368" hreflang="und">Letter</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Year</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/599" hreflang="und">1966</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Issue Info</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/600" hreflang="und">#3 / February</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="field field--name-field-pages field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Pages</div>
<div class="field-item">7-8</div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-image-link field--type-link field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Image Link</div>
<div class="field-item"><a href="http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/99">http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/99</a></div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-body field--type-text-with-summary field--label-hidden field-item"><p>[page 7] Harry Warner: 423 Summit Avenue : Hagerstown, Maryland: 21740 A lukewarm admirer of Tolkien like me found more of interest in the second Entmoot than might have been foreseen. But as you might guess, the material about music for the Tolkien poetry was the easiest for a non-student of the books to think coherently about. To think out the question of musical settings requires first of all some decisions on basics. How authentic should we be? If we search through the novels for every morsel of information about music in Middle Earth, and apply the findings to the music we create for the songs, should we also seek authenticity in the form of rejecting musical features that have evolved in the past few centuries and wouldn't have existed in the time of the hobbits and the elves except through the most improbable coincidence? I'm thinking primarily of the tempered scale that has become common property in the western music of the past couple of centuries. Some genuine folk songs in rural areas exist today without tempered intervals, using instead the "natural" intervals that were abandoned when composers wanted to modulate from key to key freely and couldn't on keyboard and most brass and woodwind instruments. Moreover, should we consider the use of harmony in the accompaniments to the Tolkien poem settings to be authentic? Harmony in the sense that we know it is extremely rare in genuine folk music, which usually gets along with nothing more elaborate than drone effects or whatever harmony comes accidentally from primitive polyphony. Even if the world of Tolkien had once existed, it would be as difficult to reconstruct accurately its music from the clues the author gives us as it is to know exactly how the Greeks sang and performed music in the age of Sophocles. So I think that the fan who wants to provide music for the Tolkien poems must make some decisions. He can create music that is consistent with what we know about the folk music of the distant past and the folk music of the more primitive races of today. He can decide that Middle Earth was such a civilized and advanced era that its music would have been considerably more sophisticated than any folk music known to us fully or in part. Or he can simply decide which sort or @of@ music known to him is most appropriate to the Tolkien poetry, in his opinion, and write new music in that style. [page 8] existed. I'd like to hear music for the Tolkien poems that was capable of making sense when sung unaccompanied, as many of the poems must have been sung. It should be melodies that sound a bit different from art or folk music that we hear frequently, perhaps through the use of one of the rarer modes, perhaps by an occasional introduction of quarter-tones. One excellent way to get away from downright imitation of existing folk music would be avoidance of strophic settings: a different melody for each stanza or alternating melodies for long poems are ways in which composed music differs from folk music, which normally repeats the same phrase (in primitive stuff) or melody endlessly with as many variations as the words in each stanza require. In any event, I imagine that there are no legal obstructions to setting the Ring volumes' poems to music, now that the copyright absence is established. I'd like to try my hand at a couple of the poems if time permitted. The only effort I've ever made of this sort involved a half dozen poems from one of Dr. David H. Keller's novels. I worked on them for months, then when I had them all copied out nicely in legible inked notation, I decided that they were no good and never let anyone else see or hear them. I confessed to Dr. Keller what I'd done and he indicated that it was just as well, because he'd thought up simple melodies himself and would have been confused if he'd encountered mine. -/That's interesting. I wonder if Tolkien....?/- The Simpson-Shaw article frightens me a little. How can I maintain my loc reputation if I must begin to learn Middle Earth penmanship to understand what I'm to comment on? -/Ha! It's all a sinister plot to get _all_ fanzines to publish totally in Elvish, so you can't comment _at all_! Hig, hig!/- However, anyone who is young and energetic enough to indulge in this has my blessings. But will the Fëanorean script be comprehended by an Irishman when written by an American? The language barrier between this country and the British Isles is already severe, and if each breed of fans writes in Middle Earth letters according to its own understanding of how English is pronounced....! -/This is the major problem. However I am assuming that those whose accent deviates markedly from standard American pronunciation, if they want to communicate in Tengwar, will refer to a dictionary. But then, I don't think that use of the Tengwar would ever catch on on a large enough scale to make this a serious problem. There are very few people interested in this rather specialized area of study--and there have been no problems yet./- What does Middle Earth mean? I don't recall any flat explanation of the term in the four Tolkien books I own. The same pair of words occurs occasionally in non-Tolkienian sources, particularly around Elizabethan times when writers seemed to use them as a sort of short- hand for reminding their readers that earth stands midway geographically and from the standpoint of happiness between heaven and hell. Is Tolkien using the words because old writers usedthem @used them@ or does he mean them to refer to a time era between prehistory and known history? -/No, since the inhabitants of Middle Earth used the term themselves. I think the Elves may have introduced it--their name for Middle Earth (ennor, or endóre) means literally 'middle-land'. There are references to only 3 great geographical areas--the Far West, Middle Earth, and the East. The Elves, coming from the West and presumably having knowledge of the East, may well have dubbed it that. I am not sure, but this has always been my idea of what he meant by Middle Earth. I suppose my readers will have many views on the matter--we'll see./-</p>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-hidden field-item">IL-00130</div>
Fri, 29 Mar 2019 19:47:26 +0000Anonymous3061 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cmsTIW: [Letter which praises Ruth Berman's song in Entmoot #3 and discussing music which might be similar to what more sophisticated Tolkien compositions might look and sound like, with in-line commentary by Greg Shaw]
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/3097
<span>TIW: [Letter which praises Ruth Berman's song in Entmoot #3 and discussing music which might be similar to what more sophisticated Tolkien compositions might look and sound like, with in-line commentary by Greg Shaw]</span>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Fri, 03/29/2019 - 19:47</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Zine Title</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/595" hreflang="und">Entmoot</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Item Type</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/368" hreflang="und">Letter</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Year</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/599" hreflang="und">1966</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Issue Info</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/601" hreflang="und">#4 / August</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="field field--name-field-pages field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Pages</div>
<div class="field-item">13-14</div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-image-link field--type-link field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Image Link</div>
<div class="field-item"><a href="http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/131">http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/131</a></div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-body field--type-text-with-summary field--label-hidden field-item"><p>[page 13] _HARRY WARNER_, _JR._ 423 Summit Avenue, Hagerstown, Maryland 21740 I thought that Ruth Berman made a shrewd choice when she linked the Tolkien poem with the Hebrew folk tune. It shouldn't be hard to memorize the melody by rote and it lies comfortably within the range of the average voice, two qualities that have been missing from some of the newly composed music I've seen to Tolkien poetry. Incidentally, anyone who is interested in more sophisticated musical versions of the Ring poetry mignt like to see how Brahms handled a set of poems vaguely reminiscent of those Tolkien wrote. He composed for voice and piano 15 poems by Ludwig Tieck, a German author. They were intersperced @interspersed@ originally by Tieck in his prose version of a 12th century Provence legend about a young man's adventures in the age of chivalry. The voice sings fairly simple melodies, frequently sounding as if it were derived from folk melody, while the piano provides quite complex accompaniments. Dietrich Fischer Dieskau recorded the whole batch on a Decca lp that has been out of the catalog for a long time but really ardent thinkers about music for Tolkien might find it in a library or college record collections, and it could conceivably be available on one of the European labels that are imported by large stores but aren't listed in the Schwann catalog. The original German poems have much more the flavor of Tolkien than the English translation; but there is the major difference that Tieck was writing about a struggle for the sake of a woman's love instead of an effort to save a people from evil and the songs reflect this romantic goal in a way that you wont find in Tolkien's poems. [page 14] I wouldn't risk any remarks on the controversies over Tolkien languages and penmanship under any circumstances. But one thing occurred to me, time after time as I read through this issue. The arrival of war would kill Tolkien fandom before it affected any other forms of fanac. Everyone mentioned in any Tolkien fanzine would be behind bars as soon as a postal censor saw all those squiggles and unknown words and decided that the whole thing was a clumsy vehicle for concealing the transmission of classified information. Both Ned Brooks and Banks Mebane give me the strangest sense that Tolkien was an author who lived and died centuries ago, on whom modern scholarship is concentrating in an effort to unearth long-forgotten secrets about meaning. Their rescarch is uncannily like some of the investigation that has been proceeding for the past couple of centuries into Shakespeare and the variations in the earliest editionsof @editions of@ his plays. If by some chance Tolkien should be recognized eventually as one of the great writers of all time, studies like these might be the keys toward unlocking mysteries that would be almost impossible to solve a couple of centuries from now. Neither, I notice, mentions the luxury edition of Tolkien that is supposed to exist; but if there is such a thing, I assume that it would be identical in text and pagination with this or that hardcover version, and would vary only in the type of binding and perhaps quality of paper. -/Right you are. Same book, including paper, as the other hardcover editions, black quality binding with gold lettering, and a little gold placemarking ribbon, and it comes in a box with illustrations on it by Pauline Baynes./- The only Hollywood figure whom I'd really want to see tested as a producer or director of Tolkien fiction is Charlie Chaplin. I don't mean that I'd like to have him turn them into comic movies. But I believe that Chaplin is one of the few Hollywood figures who had the intensity of purpose and the courage to be different, to avoid the stereotypes and obvious ways of appealing to the public. If he were young enough, if financing could be worked out, if he were interested, I believe that he would get into the spirit of the Tolkien story and make it something as distinguished and as different from the comedies that we think of when we think of Chaplin as his last two or three full-length movies were different in theme and manner from the slapstick that made him famous.</p>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-hidden field-item">IL-00169</div>
Fri, 29 Mar 2019 19:47:28 +0000Anonymous3097 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cmsSwordpoint LOC's: [Letter responding to Hoom #1, especially to articles by Frances (Jack) Scruby and Frank Denton, and discussing stories of intelligent trees]
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/3262
<span>Swordpoint LOC's: [Letter responding to Hoom #1, especially to articles by Frances (Jack) Scruby and Frank Denton, and discussing stories of intelligent trees]</span>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Fri, 03/29/2019 - 19:47</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Zine Title</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/619" hreflang="und">Hoom</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Item Type</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/368" hreflang="und">Letter</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Year</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/620" hreflang="und">1968</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Issue Info</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/622" hreflang="und">#2 / September</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="field field--name-field-pages field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Pages</div>
<div class="field-item">26-27</div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-image-link field--type-link field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Image Link</div>
<div class="field-item"><a href="http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/326">http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/326</a></div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-body field--type-text-with-summary field--label-hidden field-item"><p>[page 26] HARRY WARNER, JR. 423 Summit Ave., Hagerstown, Md., 21740 I'd better confess at the outset that I am not an all-out, 110% Tolkien fan. I've read most of his fiction and enjoyed it very much, but I find in it some faults that would be heresy to mention in the inmost Tolkien circles. Fortunately, your first issue doesn't go so deep into the more esoteric aspects of Tolkioniana, and I enjoyed the LotR items in it more than some [page 27] more pretentious major items of Tolkien scholarship I've seen in other fanzines, for the simple reason that I understood the thoughts expressed in HOOM. One thing is certain: I haven't seen a Tolkien drawing as amusing as the takeoff on Whistler on your first numbered page. The item about beryl was quite interesting, particularly for the reference to Nero. I wonder if he might have used the emerald as people today put on sun glasses, to reduce the glare? Incidentally, I couldn't help thinking all through this article about the unintentional fanzine references. A Seattle fan of the 1950's, Gertrude M. Carr, published a fanzine called GEM TONES, and instead of designating each issue by volume and number, she referred to it by the name of a gem: the first half dozen were known as the topaz, rose quartz, turquoise, opal, agate, and chrysoberyl numbers. She did it partly as a sort of pun on her first two initials, partly just for the sake of being different. Frank Denton's article caused me to think, for no particular reason of old Scottish balladry. I suppose that someone has already investigated them for possible influence on Tolkien's fiction and poetry, and I can't think of any particular ballad that is really close to the courtship and subsequent life of Tom and Goldberry. Maybe I was struck by the fact that Bombadil has the same first name as the minstral Tom who encountered the queen of the fairies one day, and was reminded by that poem's musical setting by Loewe of another Loewe-composed ballad, Der Nöck, in which a water sprite is the central figure (but there's no Tom and the water sprite has the wrong sex for this purpose). The first story about an intelligent tree that occured to me, after I read Larry Paschelke's letter, was Mr. Sycamore. I can't remember the author's name, but it dates from the 1940's, I think, and I have the uneasiest sort of suspicion that it was a Broadway play rather than a novel, or maybe both. This started with a human who simply planted himself in the earth and turned into a tree. Of course, there's the Daphne legend, which turns up in new versions occassionally, and is best known to me through the Richard Strauss opera. Please forgive my failure to come up with learned statements about Tolkien inspired by the material in this issue. I hope HOOM will find a lot of other fans in much the same position as I am, anxious to read more about Tolkien and his fiction as long as I needn't possess an expert knowledge of the Elvish tongue or ability to rattle off a century-by-century chronology of pre-War events to comprehend what I'm reading. Yrs., &c., Barry Warner, Jr.</p>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-hidden field-item">IL-00338</div>
Fri, 29 Mar 2019 19:47:37 +0000Anonymous3262 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cmsWarner, Harry Jr.
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/3628
<span>Warner, Harry Jr.</span>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">UID</div>
<div class="field-item">CL-00206</div>
</div>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Wed, 04/10/2019 - 20:22</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Sex</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/380" hreflang="und">Male</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Role</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/199" hreflang="und">Author</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Location</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/location/hagerstown" hreflang="und">Hagerstown</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
Wed, 10 Apr 2019 20:22:31 +0000Anonymous3628 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cmsSwordpoint (LOC's): [Letter responding to editor's hope in Hoom #2 that copies of round-robin tapes created by Tolkien fans exist somewhere]
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/4428
<span>Swordpoint (LOC's): [Letter responding to editor's hope in Hoom #2 that copies of round-robin tapes created by Tolkien fans exist somewhere]</span>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Tue, 02/04/2020 - 20:21</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Zine Title</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/619" hreflang="und">Hoom</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Item Type</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/368" hreflang="und">Letter</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Year</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/620" hreflang="und">1968</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Issue Info</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/623" hreflang="und">#3 / Yule</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="field field--name-field-pages field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Pages</div>
<div class="field-item">23-25</div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-image-link field--type-link field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Image Link</div>
<div class="field-item"><a href="http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/253">http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/253</a></div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-body field--type-text-with-summary field--label-hidden field-item"><p>[page 23] HARRY WARNER, JR. 423 Summit Ave., Hagerstown, Md. 21740 The second issue of HOOM was so fine to read that I feel guilt even before I start this loc. Two pages must be my limit for these things, in view of the critical condition of the growing pile of unloc'd fanzines. It seems criminal to reply to 50 pages with two pages. So I'll skip the empty line between paragraphs, after shoving the left margin control one space further back, and consider those two actions the literary equivalent of the widower's mite. I've been a member of various round robin tapes over the years. Each of them has foundered somewhere, sooner or later. I suspect that you could provide a valuable service by trying to round up a symposium on what makes a round robin tape fun and which pitfalls must be most studiously avoided. There are all sorts of unexpected problems that should be predictable but still catch participants unexpected. I remember vividly the mystery of why some new round robin tapes were vanishing without completing even one round. We discovered a common factor in these disappearances: an extremely ardent collector-type fan. It didn't take long to discover that his collecting instincts just wouldn't allow him to send on anything asaociated with fandom chat he'd acquired, even a round robin tape. The problem of having people with two-track and four-track tape recorders on the same round robin is a trifle more complicated than you suggest. There is no real difficulty if the round robin tape has one section for each participant--that is, four designated areas which are reserved for four participants. The trouble appears when the round robin has one more participant than the number [page 24] of recording areas. This is the most logical way to operate a round robin tape, because nobody really wants to listen to his last contribution the next time it comes around, and you get one more participant for x number of recording areas. But this system causes each recipient to do his recording on the area used by the person just ahead of him on the route. Some quarter-track machines will not erase completely material which was recorded on the same section by a half-track machine, and that section will contain one person's remarks at reduced volume simultaneously with the newest recording. I know of only one way to handle it: run the tape through the machine twice in recording mode, on quarter-track, without recording anything, to erase as much of the half-track recording as possible (remembering that it will require turning around the tape for the second of these erasures), then do the actual recording in the two-track position of the quarter-track taper. A bulk eraser can be used only if each person has a designated section of the tape and records both tracks on it; if this is done, the person with the quarter-track machine can cut out his section, bulk erase it, then splice it back into place again. I enjoyed very much the article by J. P. Strang. My ignorance of the finer details of Tolkien is probably showing here, but I can't help wondering if the hobbits were small because they had short legs, or because they were generally proportioned on an overall smaller scale. If it was a case of short legs, I would imagine that they would have all sorts of trouble carrying swords without tripping, unless they chose weapons small enough to be useful only against enemies of their own size. The first act of Wagner's Siegfried ends with a scene paralleling some of J. P.'s remarks about repariring and purifying swords. Siegfried breaks the sword into powder-size fragments, instead of trying to repair the two broken halves as Mime had attempted, and renames it while singing a chant-like song that gives a strong suggestion of ritual. You'll undoubtedly stir up a lot of nasty remarks by suggesting sacred music converted to Tolkienish purposes. I see nothing wrong with it; after all, a lot of celebrated sacred music was borrowed from secular sources. (I'm pretty sure that one piece of sacred music isn't even borrowed, but secular from start to finish. Everyone considered Ethelbert Nevin's _The Rosary_ to be a devout piece of religious music, and I've never been able to find anything in its words but an almost blasphemous love poem.) I tried my hand at musical settings of some poems from a fantasy novel by Dr. David H. Keller. But I can't very well offer them for your proposed tape. [page 25] because I can't sing and they're much too ambitious for anyone with the folksong-type voice that most fans possess. Tentatively, I'll consider Time of Waiting as a fairly good piece of fiction, subject to change of mind when I see the rest of it. The main criticism of this first section is the long interruption of the course of events for the explanation of what might be possible for preserving the dying woman's mind. This might be all right in a novel which goes on at a more leisurely pace but it's better in a shorter story to try to work in such backsground material discreetly, a little here and a little there, or to relate it at length when there's a clear interruption in the development of the plot. I envy Kate her love for the Oz books. I missed them when I was small and they're among the 365,772 books that I've been trying to get around to now that I'm grown up and know how much fun they can be. I picked up for a dime in the Union Rescue Mission store last week an encyclopedia of Oz, and maybe that will serve as the spur to goad me into buying some of the books themselves. Or maybe I should wait for my second childhood, which is coming fast, in the hope that the discovery would be more appropriate then. Your rundown on the steeds of fantasy was a pleasure to read, until I finished it and suddenly realized that I couldn't think of any more examples, just out of memory. I'm sure I must have read hundreds of stories in which strange mounts were ridden by heroes or villains, and I'll be blessed if I could cite chapter and verse on any of them just now. Maybe that's simply a reflection of the fact that I have gone under my own footpower most of my life and so didn't pay too much attention to how fantasy characters rode. The mailing comments made sense even though I'd seen only two or three of the magazines commented on. One advantage of the gun control laws would be their usefulness as a basis for arrest of criminals who might be connected with their crimes while in custody. Just think how often police have nabbed dangerous men on minor auto law violations, not because the cops recognized the faces or caught them in the act. My particular storage problem right now consists of finding steel shelving with braces at the back and sides. All of a sudden Sears and Montgomery Ward have started to sell only the non-braced type, and despite the claims, they simply aren't able to hold heavy stuff like records without becoming shaky and tilted. Now I've gone and omitted all mention of the art, poetry, and various other things. Please forgive and take for granted that I would have been specific about them if they'd been really bad or objectionable. Yrs., &c., Harry Warner, Jr.</p>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-hidden field-item">IL-00381</div>
Tue, 04 Feb 2020 20:21:26 +0000Anonymous4428 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cmsOpere Citato
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/4443
<span>Opere Citato</span>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Tue, 05/12/2020 - 21:22</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Zine Title</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/1027" hreflang="x-default">Riverside Quarterly</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Item Type</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/373" hreflang="und">Article</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Year</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/620" hreflang="und">1968</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Issue Info</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/1026" hreflang="x-default">#3.2 / March</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="field field--name-field-pages field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Pages</div>
<div class="field-item">146-149</div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-image-link field--type-link field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Image Link</div>
<div class="field-item"><a href="http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/1054">http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/1054</a></div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-body field--type-text-with-summary field--label-hidden field-item"><p>[page 146] opere citato BY HARRY WARNER, JR. Sometimes the negative approach comes closest to getting things explained. It would help, for instance, to point out that this is not a new fanzine review column. It appeared regularly in Gregg Calkins' _Oopsla!_ five or six years ago. Next, it is not the kind of fanzine review which synopsizes and expresses opinions on a group of fanzines chosen as the most recently arrived or the best of the recent arrivals. Nor does it make an effort to be totally comprehensive on the particular aspect of fanzines that gets attention in each instalment. Finally, the writer, while welcoming fanzines for review purposes, can't guarantee that any given publication will fit neatly enough into the column's subject-matter to get reviewed. Since this column last emerged into print, the fanzine field has undergone significant changes. There are more fanzines than ever before, principally because of those very changes: specialised subfandoms have become more prominent in the preoccupation with one author or one type of fantasy; the amateur press associations have been born slightly faster than other amateur press associations have died, a considerable feat; and fandom has begun publishing on a major scale in a half-dozen nations on the continent of Europe. The dividing line between fandom and prodom has been breached repeatedly, with definite effects on the kind of material appearing in many fanzines and the appearance of the material in a few other fanzines. The very word "fanzine" has not yet appeared in dictionaries, but it has been used in a mass circulation magazine like _TV Guide_ calmly and without an explanatory footnote. Some developments in fan publishing have been dwarfed by these obvious trends. But the less obvious changes could turn out to provide in the future some of the most important influences on fandom as a whole. I have been impressed by the manner in which colleges and universities are without deliberate intent or fanfare beginning to produce more and more clusters of fans among their student-bodies. This is not a new phenomenon, of course. The Massachusetts Institute of Technology Science Fiction Society originated in the early 1950's. The Science Fiction Society of City College of New York was formed in 1961. Miami University of Ohio organised a Science Fiction Association in 1949. UCLA claimed 78 members for its science fiction club when Forrest Ackerman discovered it in 1949. The University of Chicago Science Fiction Club started in 1952 or earlier. [page 147] OPERE CITATO But there was a difference in the 1940's and 1950's. Science fiction groups on the campus were frosting on the cake then. The bulk of fandom was still recruited from the reader sections in the prozines. Today, the letter sections, fanzine reviews, and club columns in the prozines are almost one with Nineveh and Tyre. More and more new fans are being recruited in the classrooms: either because a solitary fan finds a fellow student who reads science fiction, or because there is a formal science fiction club sanctioned by the school. This is not as undependable a site for recruiting new fans as you might assume. Most young people read at least a small amount of science fiction, and a state university with enrollment of 40,000 or so provides as many potential new fans as the prozine that used to have trouble selling 50,000 copies of each issue. The eventual result could be both a continuing source of new fans and a difference in the whole makeup of the average fan. Those that come from the campus may be expected to possess at least a minimal amount of intelligence developed into thinking habits. The prozine-derived fan was sometimes eleven years old and unable to act his age. Symbolic of what might become the future norm is a present exception to the general run of fanzines. The eighth issue of _Golana_, "published at semi-irregular intervals by and for the students of the Brooklyn Polytechnic Institute," contains in its 54 pages such luxuries as multi-colour covers, professional reproduction with most of its text in letterpress typefaces, and one absolute novelty in my experience for a fanzine: remarkable calligraphy by John Closson which provides each of the poems with its own distinctive and theme-fitting style of lettering. The bulk of the prose is fiction, most of which possesses the freshness of approach and technical inadequacies that you'll find in most stories by good students. Fandom in general seems little aware of this publication or its staff: John Hoffman, John Najberg, Marshall Schwartz, Reggie Barry, Bob Mattson, Jef Bienenfeld, Edward V. Dong, Gilbert Wachsman, Allan E. Levy, and so forth are hardly the names you hear dropped at worldcons. They should produce many thuds if their publishing interest survives graduation. Not nearly as elegant in appearance is _Hugin and Munin_. This publication by fans at Carleton University, Ottawa, Ontario, seems to have resulted from spontaneous combustion: its first issue appeared from the hands of a group of new fans who had seen only one issue of one fanzine in their collective lives, and decided to put out their own magazine before any more fanzines arrived. The second issue, with some 44 dittoed pages, emanates the unforgettable aura of slightly unbridled enthusiasm that can come only when a bunch of new fans have grown active almost simultaneously. The local readership is inexperienced enough to find useful a list of science fiction novels which aren't labeled as such by the publishers, but sophisticated enough to have published a useful checklist of the fiction of Roger Zelazny. The editor is Richard Labonte, who has become a fairly familiar name in fandom by now, and there are lots more where he came from, for we learn that _Hugin and Munin_ has an on-campus circulation of 200. [page 148] HARRY WARNER The halls of academe can have other influences on the fan magazine field. Consider the case of the Tolkien fans. As everyone should know by now, the Ring novels have had three incarnations: the first, when they won a _succès d'estime_ in the general literary world, the second, when general fandom discovered them and incubated within them a subfandom devoted to the author, and the third, when their paperback publication in the United States produced unexpectedly large sales, with particular demand in college towns. In volume 3, number 2, of _The Tolkien Journal_, editor Dick Plotz describes the current state of affairs in the most graphic possible terms: "There is no returning to the days when one could write messages on subway walls in Elvish and expect that they would remain confidential." He reports himself impossibly swamped by the demands for memberships in and services of his Tolkien Society of America. College fandom came to his rescue: Ed Meskys, an instructor in physics at Belknap College, Center Harbor, New Hampshire, offered his computer for the good of Middle Earth, since it can relieve the burden of addressing envelopes; and he "hopes to take advantage of other opportunities at Belknap which would enable him to take over most of the functions of the TSA with much less effort. The button-book-poster business may have to go to someone else," Plotz warns, as a reminder that fandom must still show some self-reliance and cannot be certain that institutions of higher learning will do all the work involved in distributing the travel poster, "Come to Middle Earth," prepared by Barbara Remington, or the lapel button that urges, "Support Your Local Hobbit." Still another phase in the evolution of college fanzines is provided by a whole slew of publications emerging from a large geographical area in the general environs of MIT. _The Twilight Zine_ has long been coming from MIT's science fiction club. As the years pass, the institution's graduates have formed occasional isolated colonies elsewhere in the nation, while back at headquarters, something odd happened: the editors became Cory Seidman and Leslie Turek, who initially surprised fans elsewhere by turning out to be feminine, and then startled MIT graduates by admitting that they weren't MIT students, either. In the first issue of _The Proper Boskonian_, Cory writes: "Leslie and I have long realized how unusual it was for two non-MIT undergraduates to be editing an MIT fanzine. Now that we are non-MIT non-undergraduates, the situation is nearly unendurable." As a result, college fandom in New England is entering its second generation through the creation of the New England Science Fiction Association, which has begun to emit several small publications while in its formative stage. [page 149] OPERE CITATO Meanwhile, the recent history of the MIT Science Fiction Society shows how useful a university's equipment and finances can be for large fan projects. MIT funds made possible the production two years ago of Erwin Strauss's index to 1951-1965 science fiction magazines, and it has turned into a best seller by fandom's standards: 700 copies had sold, at last reports, and a supplement covering 1966 had been issued. Without financial assistance, Mike Ward organised the Technology Amateur Press Association, the only school-centred apa in my experience, It survived through ten distributions until its recent demise. Released in October was the third issue of _Bibliographica Futurica Fantastica_, the latest MIT project. Edwin W. Meyer hopes to make it the only complete source of information on "all recently published and forthcoming science fiction, fantasy and off-trail literature published in this country and abroad with descriptive details." A dozen pages of listings are included in this issue, together with instructions for using the elaborate system of symbols and keys to the bibliographical information and classification of each novel. These listings rely too much on publishers' blurbs for some titles and provide no supplemental information at all about other books, but regular publication of this service would be stupendously useful for research workers and collectors. _The Twilight Zine_ itself has reached its 22nd issue, evidence that fanzines can show academic influence without being too serious about it. The minutes of the MITSFS meetings reveal that the organisation voted to censure NASA because of dissapointment @disappointment@ with its estimate of the quantity of molecules at the surface of Mars, and discovered that a Selectric ball furnished with Elvish characters could be ordered for $215. Nineteen stanzas, to be sung to "Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star," are devoted to Maxwell's equations, starting out: "Oscillate, oscillate, e-m wave; / Maxwell's equations will make you behave." {Divider: A short line made of hypens divides the text above from that below.} _Golana_: Edward V. Dong, editor in chief, Brooklyn Polytechnic Institute, 333 Jay St., Brooklyn, New York 11201, care of Box 439; no price specified. _Hugin and Munin_: Richard Labonte, editor, 971 Walkley Road, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, 25¢ per issue. _The Tolkien Journal_: Edmund R. Meskys, Physics Dept., Belknap College, Center Harbor, New Hampshire 03226, $l per issue. _The Proper Boskonian_: Cory Seidman, 20 Ware St., Cambridge, Mass., 02138, included in $2.50 subscribing membership in New England Science Fiction Association. _Bibliographica Futurica Fantastica_: Edwin W. Meyer, Box E, MIT Station, Cambridge, Mass., 02139, six issues for $l.50. _The Twilight Zine_: MIT Science Fiction Society Room W20-443, MIT, 77 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, Mass. ,02139; 25¢ per issue.</p>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-hidden field-item">IL-00771</div>
Tue, 12 May 2020 21:22:59 +0000Anonymous4443 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cmsOpere Citato
https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/node/4446
<span>Opere Citato</span>
<span><span lang="" typeof="schema:Person" property="schema:name" datatype="" xml:lang="">Anonymous (not verified)</span></span>
<span>Tue, 05/12/2020 - 21:22</span>
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Zine Title</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/1027" hreflang="x-default">Riverside Quarterly</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Creator</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/531" hreflang="und">Warner, Harry Jr.</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Item Type</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/373" hreflang="und">Article</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Year</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/620" hreflang="und">1968</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="node-taxonomy-container">
<h3 class="term-title">Issue Info</h3>
<ul class="taxonomy-terms">
<li class="taxonomy-term"><a href="https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms/taxonomy/term/1028" hreflang="x-default">#3.3 / August</a></li>
</ul>
</div> <!--/.node-taxonomy-container -->
<div class="field field--name-field-pages field--type-string field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Pages</div>
<div class="field-item">234-237</div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-image-link field--type-link field--label-inline">
<div class="field__label">Image Link</div>
<div class="field-item"><a href="http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/1065">http://cdm16280.contentdm.oclc.org/cdm/ref/collection/p16280coll10/id/1065</a></div>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-body field--type-text-with-summary field--label-hidden field-item"><p>[page 234] opere citato BY HARRY WARNER, JR. DISJECTA MEMBRA Strife and disorder have arisen over a question of definition. The Hugo categories established in 1967 for fan achievements were won by some people, who had professional credentials: author Alexei Panshin and artist Jack Gaughan. Objections were based on the claim that simon pure amateurs should receive awards intended for fan accomplishments. Those who objected overlooked the fact that it is increasingly difficult to separate the professionals from the amateurs. Perhaps half of the best material written for fanzines today emerges from typewriters of people who have professional taint, in or out of science fiction and fantasy; there are novelists, editors, copyreaders, journalists, teachers of English, agents, and members of a smattering of other professions somehow related to the written or the published word. It's curious that the opposite complaint wasn't lodged about Hugo awards. A sizable proportion of Hugo awards for professional science fiction has gone to men who have made one or more recent appearances in fanzines. By the logic that criticises the awards for amateur accomplishment, there should be objections to the categorising of a Zelazny or an Ellison as a professional writer. Fortunately, this type of logic has no effect on the professional qualities of the prose that normally appears in fanzines under the byline of men who have made their reputations primarily on the basis of the things they wrote for pay rather than for play. And the freshet of fanzines that has arisen as if by sympathetic magic from the swollen waterways of the continent during this abnormally wet spring contains an unusually generous plenitude of material by widely known professional writers. At the risk of invalidating completely the Hugo voting for several years to come, let's look at some of the fanzine material that has been more rewarding to the readers than to the writers. Perhaps the biggest difference between today's and yesterday's fanzine material by professionals is this: the pros no longer show much reluctance to speak plainly about their compatriots and about people with other types of professional functions. [page 235] OPERE CITATO As recently as the 1950's, Jim Blish was using his William Atheling pen name when he wrote critically about science fiction; today we almost never find a little note at the top of a fanzine article explaining that "the writer is a professional who for ethical reasons prefers to remain anonymous." Thus, we find in the March issue of _Psychotic_ two appearances by Norman Spinrad, who fiercely defends science fiction and says plain things about this type of literature in the process. "There have never been thirty-two great sf writers alive at the same time in human history," he says in a review of the Ellison anthology, _Dangerous Visions_. This hardly sounds like a heretical attitude today but there was a less realistic era when it would have been assayed as a body blow to scores of clean-living, morally fit backwriters. Spinrad likes the anthology and the manner in which Ellison "set impossible goals for the writers to reach; by striving for the impossible some of the writers might be goaded into achieving the merely highly improbable." In another article in the same issue, Spinrad sets himself the modest goal of describing "why and how science fiction is destroying and castrating its best writers." At considerable length and in the most convincing manner, he details his contention that "in the eyes of the majority of publishers, editors and hucksters in the field, science fiction is something to be written for children. No...it's worse than that: science fiction is something to be written to satisfy what so-called adults imagine to be the tastes of children." The March-April issue of _Kallikanzaros_ doesn't reveal the origin and routing of the material by Kurt Vonnegut that it publishes. It's a transcript of a speech whose where and when is not revealed. But from internal evidence it's fairly recent and was heard at a college or university somewhere in Ohio. The written version of a talk is frequently an appalling travesty of the original form, even when the transcript is accurate, because there's so much difference between effective spoken and effective written language. But Vonnegut even provides amusement with his jokes in this published version, the severest test of all. He starts by giving a three-minute course in the art of writing the short story--a horizontal line, occasionally intersected by another line which rises and falls in accord with the state of the hero's fortunes. Toward the end Vonnegut becomes quite serious about books and the reasons why they must not become obsolete. "In order to be free we must have much new information coming from people facing life this very day. The cheapest way to do it is with a book," and because only two or three people are major influences on that book--the writer, the editor, and maybe the editor's boss--it can reveal individual human experiences, instead of the committee-type expression of a film." A different approach to the goal of better science fiction is followed by Mike Moorcock in "By Spaceship to the Psyche," published in the April issue of _Les Spinge_, as a reprint from a previous issue of the same publication. It is one of the rare voices emerging from the wilderness in defense of the new wave school of science fiction. A Ballard novel is described as "a definite breakthrough not only for science fiction, but for a new kind of literature that is beginning to emerge from the Mean Ages." William Burroughs' "experimental novels" are "science fiction as it must become if it is to survive as anything but a superficial form of entertainment." [page 236] HARRY WARNER Moorcock sees Cordwainer Smith as one of the pioneers in the journeys away from the more orthodox patterns of looking at the world and writing about it. "He is a writer who sees in the developments of modern physics a future world of brilliance, mediocrity, cruelty and wonder. He draws, his inspirations from inside, not from the Sunday supplement science page." {Image: A line drawing of an iron person standing before a science fiction building appears to the left of the first paragraph. The person is shown from the shoulders up. Instead of ears, he sports two circular devices where ears would be. An insignia of a bird motif appears on the figure's cylindrical forehead. The figure wears a heavy jacket. The science fiction building or complex, appears to the right of the figure.} Roger Zelazny has been appearing almost as frequently in fanzines as in professional pastures. The October-November, 1967 issue of _Hugin and Munin_ was distributed only when Spring was arriving, at a time when a couple of major science fiction movies were ready for release generally. _Planet of the Apes_ and a couple of other productions have begun to get cautiously favourable reviews in the fan press, but Zelazny is pessimistic about the general usefulness of film as a medium for science fiction. He feels that there is a great burden of sin to expiate, in the form of the vast quantities of terrible science fiction movies up to now; he fears that the very nature of the film is difficult to equate with the imagination that should be the reader's contribution to a science fiction story; and finally, he warns "that if you want to make SF popular you'll have to water it down for popular consumption and cater to the popular consumer...and in a sense, therefore, we would have to pimp for it." John Hayden Howard is not a professional name that automatically induces a mental genuflecting gesture for the science-fiction reader. But _The Eskimo Invasion_ has begun to make it better Known @known@, and the author has appeared at least twice in fanzines of recent date, once in reply to an unfavourable review and again over a sort of story behind the story similar to the ancient _Thrilling Wonder Stories_ feature. In the February issue of _Speculation_, Howard tells how the novel was influenced by his skin-diving adventures in the 1950's, his attempt in 1960 to integrate that hobby into science fiction, and the eventual amalgamation of the population explosion with his previous thoughts. "The Esks represent population pressure regardless of race, colour, creed or country of national origin, " Howard says. "The rest of the people in the novel may represent the rest of mankind--although I hope not!" [page 237] OPERE CITATO He defines the disastrous turn of events in the novel as inspired by this difficulty: "The problem of the multiplying Esks was too big for any man. Because nations acted for their short-term interests rather than for their long-term imperatives, and were as unable to cooperate in popular control as they have been in nuclear arms control, all men failed. There was chaos when there need not have been." The line between prodom and fandom seems to grow less clearly defined. We find John D. MacDonald, who has written fantasy in addition to suspense and mystery, writing letters of comment and requesting help from fandom in identifying the places of publication of some of his early stories. Ted White, who has made the transition from fandom to prodom, suddenly begins to review mystery novels for a fanzine. A Tolkien-slanted fanzine paints an unforgettable picture of W.H. Auden wandering through a Tolkien fan meeting, holding a copy of a fanzine, and baffled not by any of its slang or in-group jokes but by the identity of a mundane novelist mentioned therein. So maybe it's time to stop segregating verbally the two manifestations of one breed. If there should be wider distribution of the concept that it is quite possible to do some writing and drawing for the fun of it, without destroying one's ability to earn money with the typewriter or pen, we should have a friendlier attitude when a Hugo is about to be awarded, and increased quantities of high quality material in fanzines. {Divider: A short line made of hyphens separates the text above from that below.} _Psychotic_: Richard E. Geis, 5 Westminster Ave., Venice, California 90291, 25¢ per issue. _Kallikanzaros_: John Ayotte, 1121 Pauline Ave., Columbus, Ohio 43224, 35¢ per issue or four for $1.25. _Les Spinge_: Darroll Pardoe, 95 E. Twelfth Ave., Columbus, Ohio 43201, no price listed. _Hugin and Munin_: Richard Labonte, 971 Walkley Road, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, 25¢ per issue. _Speculation_: Peter R. Weston, 81 Trescott Road, Northfield, Birmingham 31, England, 30¢ per copy or three for $1.00. EDITOR'S UNSOLICITED ANNOUNCEMENTS Admirers of John D. Macdonald should contact Len Moffat (9826 Paramount Blvd., Downey, Calif. 90240), editor of _The JDM Bibliophile_. // Fans with poor eyesight are cautioned that _Les Spinge_ is now printed in elite micro-type (which would make reading difficult) and in _purple_--which removes the contrast ordinarily provided by black-on-white and makes reading virtually impossible. Such preciosity, I think, is motivated by the same source that sometimes prompts editors of Little @little@ magazines to abandon punctuation and print exclusively in lower case. // I just learned that Richard Geis no longer lives in California, so anything mailed to _Psychotic_ presumably is forwarded to Governor Ron Reagan.</p>
</div>
<div class="field field--name-field-uid field--type-string field--label-hidden field-item">IL-00774</div>
Tue, 12 May 2020 21:22:59 +0000Anonymous4446 at https://tolkien.raynordslab.org/cms