Zine Title

Creator

Item Type

Year

Issue Info

Pages
26

[page 26] ADDENDA TO NO MONROE IN LOTHLORIEN (I PALANTIR 3) Next time you're in a large public library, try to get hold of a collasal tome called "Romanesque Art in Italy", by H. Decker ( translated from the German ) published by Thames and Hardhan. It includes 230 very fine photographs, and three of these show possible sites for the filming of scenes in Minas Tirith; plates 74 and 75 show views in and of the little wall hill-town of SAN GIMIGNANO, which is one of the only Italian towns still to possess a number of the private family fortified houses common in the Middle Ages, with their great fortified towers standing up above the roof-lines,overtopping even the church towers. Plate 76 shows the very remarkable fortified hill-top of MONTERIGGIONO to give its modern Italian name ). It's a great forty-foot high curtain wall surrounding the whole hill-top, with a set of 14 big square towers each some 90 ft. high at equal intervals all around it, leaving the whole thing looking like an out-size embodiment of the ornament called in heraldry a "moral crown." I am wondering whether it might not be best to do the film partly in cartoon (you'll remember that mixed cartoon and actual shots _can_ be done ) as otherwise the difficulties about the orcs, or, even worse, the Ents, become simply impossible. But I shiver to think what Disney would make of it -- we'd want somebody with all his technical skill, but something as unlike his ( alleged ) "artistic" conceptions as possible! ( You remember the scornful side-swipes that Tolkien takes at him in passing, in several places!) Unfortunately the man we really want for this, died some thirty years ago; he was an artist who had great influence on C.S. Lewis ( and I believe also on Tolkien ) being the late Arthur Rackham. I don't know whether you ever saw any of his illustrations to Grimm's Fairy Tales or to the Wagnerian "Ring" Cycle, but they are most striking, since he had a wonderful gift for fantasy and for "atmosphere." He could draw a tree in such a way that you found yourself turning it round and round trying to decide what there was about it that caused it to look at the same time perfectly natural and also horribly threatening! Clarke Ashton Smith, in his earliest days when he illustrated his own ta les @tales@, sometimes brought this off, ,while I'm told that Sime could, and, of course, a great master in this line was the Italian immigrant who settled in England at the beginning of the nineteenth century, Fuseli. Doc Weir